Compare Fuel Cards

Being one of the largest independent fuel card agents, we offer a considerable number of different fuel cards, all tailored to different needs. We want to help you choose the right one for your business.

Our fuel card comparison chart

That’s why we have developed a chart to help you make that comparison quickly. Below, you can see the different features and benefits offered by leading providers. We also have our Select Fuel Card tool which, after only four simple questions will give you up to three fuel cards that will meet your criteria.

Brand Fuel Card Total Network Coverage Pricing Type What sites can the card be used at PIN Required? Can I collect loyalty points with my card
Allstar One 7,600 Pump Related 98% of all sites across the UK Yes, at Keyfuels sites only Some sites may accept your loyalty card
BP Bunker 1,225 Fixed Price BP only Yes No
BP One 3,550 List Price BP, Esso, Gulf, Texaco Yes BPme Rewards
BP Plus 3,550 Pump Related BP, Esso, Gulf, Texaco Yes BPme Rewards
Esso Commercial 1,300 Fixed Price Esso only Esso sites only Nectar Points
Gulf, Pace and EMO 2,500 Pump Related Gulf, Pace and Emo plus all sites that display the Keyfuels logo Unmanned sites only No
Keyfuels 3,400 Fixed Price Morrisons and Tesco supermarkets, plus all sites that display the Keyfuels logo Unmanned sites only Tesco Clubcard at Tesco sites
Shell CRT 1,050 Fixed Price Shell only Shell sites only Shell Go+
Shell Multifleet Over 3,800 Pump Related Shell, Circle K, Esso, Gleaner, Gulf, Morrisons, Texaco Shell sites only Shell Go+
Shell One Over 3,800 List Price Shell, Circle K, Esso, Gleaner, Gulf, Morrisons, Texaco Shell sites only Shell Go+
Shell Electric Vehicle Over 7,500 charge points and over 3,800 sites for traditional fuel Pump Related Shell Recharge plus 18 partner sites including NewMotion, Ionity, ChargePoint, ESB and EV-Box No PIN required – uses RFID technology (contactless) Shell Go+
Texaco Fastfuel 3,650 Fixed Price Texaco, Co-Op Morrisons and Tesco supermarkets, plus all sites that display the UK Fuels logo Texaco and unmanned sites only Tesco Clubcard at Tesco sites
UK Fuels 3,350 Fixed Price Co-Op, Morrisons and Tesco supermarkets, plus all sites that display the UK Fuels logo Unmanned sites only Tesco Clubcard at Tesco sites

This table shows a high-level summary of some of the features and benefits of our fuel cards.
Please note that certain cards, sites and products carry an additional handling fee.

Found the right fuel card for your fleet?

How to compare fuel cards

While there are obvious benefits to checking the total number of sites offered by a fuel card provider, how accessible those sites are based on your routes, and the types of benefits you could enjoy, it’s also important to understand how the cards are priced.

Common fuel card pricing models include:

  • Pump related cards are priced according to the forecourt pump price, and some of these off-network sites do carry an additional handing fee.
  • Fixed price cards offer you a fixed weekly diesel (and / or unleaded) price at certain sites on the network (Core or Bunker sites). Some of the sites for fixed priced cards do carry an additional handling fee.
  • List price cards also offer a fixed price on diesel (and / or unleaded) and some sites do carry an additional handling fee.

Choosing your fuel card at face value can be difficult, and we’d advise contacting our dedicated fuel card experts for tailored insights into exactly which card is right for your commercial fleet.

Why compare fuel cards?

Every commercial fleet looks slightly different, with factors such as vehicle type, fuel type, and route locations ultimately influencing which fuel card fits the bill. Taking the time to compare fuel cards and making an informed decision is the best way to make sure that the fuel card you select is a good fit for your business. Some key considerations to make include:

Value

Fuel cards are there to help you save money, but to optimise your savings it’s important to ensure that your fuel card is ticking all the right boxes. Try to reconcile your fuel card usage with your route planning to ensure that the card you select provides optimal coverage for all of your drivers, and think about the types of petrol station your drivers can refill at.

Benefits

While fuel cards share a common purpose, each individual card often comes with a different set of benefits. Comparing fuel cards based on these benefits can help you find a good mix of prices, coverage, and benefits that are tailored to your needs.

HMRC-compliant invoicing (removing the need to save receipts), servicing and repairs discounts, and wider coverage are just a few examples of the benefits a card could offer. Make an informed choice and make your card go that little bit further.

Choose the right fuel card for your needs

Each fuel card comes with its own specifications, limitations, and rewards. Our handy comparison table helps you to make a well-informed decision about the fuel card you choose.

Keep your fleet in motion and make the most of the benefits they offer to help you bolster your savings.

About Fuel Card Services

Fuel Card Services is one of the UK’s largest fuel card providers, offering our customers a wide range of fuel cards that can be used at various sites throughout the UK, helping to keep their fleets moving. 

We also offer a range of fleet-related products including:

  • Telematics.
  • Discounted service, maintenance and repair for car and van fleets.
  • Mileage capture systems for business and personal mileage.
  • Daily vehicle walk around checks to ensure vehicles are safe to use.

Our customer-focused approach

Our customers can select which fleet products best suit their needs and budgets via our online portal MyFleetHub.  To help our customers manage the services they get from us at a price that fits with their requirements, MyFleetHub gives complete transparency about what fleet services they receive, when they receive them and at what price.  A range of adjacent services are also available from Fuel Card Services including Card Protect for fuel cards to protect against card lost, CO2Count to track fleet greenhouse gas emissions, MileageCount for tracking simple journeys to split business and personal mileage.

Some Fuel Card Services customers avail of the Fleet Tool Box on our website which allows customers to store vehicle and driver information, keep track of driver licence details and calculate the cost of running your fleet with our smart calculator.  Customers have the opportunity to trial these services at no cost for a period of time; after the trial period, customers pay a small monthly fee and can terminate any services at any time by just giving us a call or dropping us an email.

 Anyone making an online application or calling to enquire about our services will be given a full explanation of how all of these products work, the fees chargeable, how to end any services no longer required, and how to find out answers to any other questions they may have about how to get best value from their fuel cards.  All of this information and more is also available in our welcome pack.  We love talking to our customers and potential customers – if you want to find out anything about how we can help you better manage your fleet, get in touch today.